The Executive Persona: 3 Myths vs. Realities of the “Perfect” C-Suite Candidate
In every executive search, there’s the brief — and then there’s the bias. Most boards and hiri...
Read More
5 Unspoken Rules of Executive Search You Need to Know to Negotiate Compensation
What no one tells you about landing and thriving in a C-suite role
At the executive level, the rules of the game aren’t always written down — but they’re very much in play. While the stakes are higher and the opportunities more complex, the process is rarely transparent. Whether you’re stepping into your first C-suite role or preparing for your next, understanding the unspoken rules can be the difference between being considered and being chosen.
Here’s 5 rules of engagement that you won’t find in the job description — but should absolutely know:
1. You’re Always Being Evaluated — Not Just in the Interview
From the first outreach to the final offer, you’re under the microscope. Executive recruiters and boards alike are assessing how you communicate, how you follow up, and how you carry yourself in off-the-record conversations. Remember: the evaluation starts before the interview and often continues long after. Your online presence, your network’s opinion of you, and even how you handle scheduling logistics can shape the perception of your candidacy.
2. The Search Firm Works for the Client — But Advocates for the Candidate Too
While it’s true that executive search firms are hired by companies, the best firms operate with a dual mandate: finding the right fit for both the business and the individual. As a candidate, it’s important to build authentic relationships with recruiters. Be candid about what you want — and what you don’t. We’re not just vetting you; we’re also your sounding board, your market guide, and at times, your fiercest advocate.
3. Culture Fit > Resume Fit
Yes, your track record matters. But no one’s hiring a CV. Companies want someone who can navigate board dynamics, inspire teams, and reflect the values of the organization — especially during periods of transformation. Technical skills might get you in the door; cultural alignment gets you the offer.
4. Your Reputation Will Precede You
Expect backchannel reference checks — it’s industry standard. Clients want to know how you lead in real life, not just on paper. Assume your past board members, colleagues, and even former direct reports may be quietly asked for their opinions. Your digital footprint matters too. Are you seen as a thought leader? Are your values visible?
5. Hidden Biases in C-Suite Hiring
Despite progress, biases still linger. Some organizations still favor pedigrees: elite schools, Fortune 500 logos, or certain industries. This can disadvantage exceptional leaders from nontraditional backgrounds. My advice? Own your story. Translate your impact across sectors. Proactively address perceived “gaps” as strengths — agility, cross-industry insight, or resilience. And know this: the right company will value substance over symbolism.
Use these Rules for Negotiating Power, Not Just Pay. At this level, it’s not just what you earn — it’s what you own. A compelling C-suite package includes decision-making authority, strategic visibility, and equity. When negotiating, ask the real questions:
- Why did the last leader leave?
- What’s the quality of the team I’m inheriting?
- How is equity structured in the case of a sale or exit?
Don’t settle for scope that’s vague or unrealistic. Clarify expectations, define success, and negotiate from a place of value — not fear.
3 Common Negotiation Pitfalls – Many executives still make these 3 critical missteps when evaluating an offer that can effect their leverage and outcome when negotiating the position, such as:
- Over-focusing on salary and ignoring long-term incentives (equity, bonuses, exit terms)
- Failing to ask about team dynamics or role expectations
- Not pressing for clarity on why the role is open or what internal politics may be in play
And yes — compensation disparities persist, especially for women and underrepresented leaders, so don’t be afraid to push for transparency. Do you research of the role and the company, ask to see ranges early, benchmark with peers and be realistic about market conditions and your experience level when negotiating. If the company resists having these important conversations, that may be a red flag and your cue to exit.
Executive search is not a level playing field — but it can be navigated with clarity, strategy, and the right relationships. The best candidates understand that the process isn’t just about landing the job. It’s about positioning yourself as the kind of leader companies can’t afford to overlook.
If you’re ready to step into your next chapter, let’s make sure you’re seen, heard, and ready to lead. If you have any questions about hiring talented C-Suite leaders or looking for your next executive role, reach out to me anytime at [email protected] or 954-994-1340.
About the Author: Lauren Casta is the Managing Director – Central & North Florida – Finance & Accounting Search at StevenDouglas and services Central and North Florida bringing over a decade of both financial recruiting, as well as hands-on accounting and finance experience to the role. She has a track record of success identifying top talent for some of the most notable companies in NE Florida, and previous experience at a leading, global firm focused on Accounting and Finance. Throughout Lauren’s career, she has made a range of placements from Staff Accountant to CFO, and every role in between. Her expertise spans a variety of industries with many kinds of organizations, from mid-market companies to billion-dollar corporations.
