The Founder’s Trap: How the Best Builders Become the Biggest Bottleneck
There’s a moment most founders know well, even if they’ve never put words to it. It’s the mo...
Read More
5 Company Culture Deal Breakers
A hiring expert explains why employees stay and what issues make them leave a company
In today’s workplace, attracting and retaining top talent is no longer just an HR function, and instead has become a priority across C-Suite and upper management. It’s a strategic imperative for success to find quality, high-impact employees that are engaged in the company’s mission and committed to long-term growth within the organization. Despite headlines suggesting a soft economy or an employer’s market, the reality of what I’m seeing with many of the companies I work with every day tells a much different story. Repeatedly, I’m seeing senior-level talent with three to five years of executive leadership experience remain in high demand, particularly in competitive markets like South Florida. Companies that assume they can pay less, offer less, or disengage from culture building, are risking higher turnover, lost productivity, and long-term damage to engagement from the top down.
The most successful organizations understand that culture is what separates them from competitors seeking similar talent. Compensation, which once was the most attractive lure for potential hires and long-term employees alike, still matters. But it’s only one piece of what is now a much larger equation of why top talent stays with a company long-term.
Deal breaker #1 – Leadership doesn’t practice what they preach
Culture starts at the top and is established by what leaders do, not what they say. When executives serve as role models, by demonstrating transparency, accessibility, and accountability, they send a clear message about what the organization stands for. Open-door policies, genuine mentorship and consistent communication help eliminate the “corner office” mentality and replace it with trust.
The modern leader, from the C-suite through to senior managers, must exemplify this shift because their dispositions and attitudes will be replicated by those they manage, as well as permeate the culture they lead. By actively asking team members what they enjoy about their roles, including what could be “twice as good”, as well as what they’d like to change, leaders can show that their feedback is welcomed and valued. Taking employee suggestions to the next level and putting them into action shows that listening isn’t symbolic, it’s operational.
Deal breaker #2 – You aren’t making hybrid work…work
Hybrid work is no longer a perk, it’s an expectation. The challenge isn’t where people work, but how they stay connected. Flexibility matters and finding the right balance between in-office and remote work is critical to engagement, and ultimately retention. Leaders who rigidly resist hybrid models often discover they’re no longer competitive or a sought-after Employer of Choice.
Creating connections in a hybrid model must be deliberate and authentic. Regular all-hands meetings, transparent updates on company performance, and shared visibility into wins and challenges help employees feel secure and included. When leaders openly share whether business is strong or soft and take the time to honestly explain what that means, employees feel respected and trusted. That trust becomes especially powerful during uncertain times
Small rituals also make a big difference. Starting meetings with personal check-ins before diving into business builds relationships. Celebrating birthdays, hosting monthly lunches, or holding team-building events reinforces the idea that people and their lives and input matter beyond their output.
Deal breaker #3 – No access to growth and development
Retention is deeply tied to a person’s ability to feel like real development is happening as well as personal betterment and career advancement is available to them. Employees want to learn, grow, be challenged and feel like the pursuit of a successful career and outcome is not theirs alone, but supported by the company, especially those whom they report to. Structured opportunities, like training sessions, lunch-and-learns and peer-led workshops, allow people to develop new skills while reinforcing that their expertise is displayed and valued.
The most effective programs are collaborative. Ask employees what they want to learn, then empower internal subject-matter experts to lead sessions. The result is shared ownership of growth. This also flattens hierarchies and gives people a platform to lead, teach, reach and innovate.
Innovation thrives when it’s not confined to leadership. Encouraging employees at every level to find better, faster or more efficient ways to do their jobs unlocks creativity across the organization. Task forces, pilot programs and “super user” teams allow employees to test new tools, refine processes and champion change, and turn innovation into a shared mission, rather than a top-down directive.
Deal breaker #4 – You’re not managing the whole person
The best cultures recognize employees as whole people. Flexibility, meaningful time off, and trust-based policies, like unlimited PTO for experienced professionals, signal respect and autonomy. Asking questions first, being open and showing that you recognize every person has their own story, maybe dealing with a personal struggle or having non-work responsibilities pushing them over their bandwidth is a great practice to create authentic connections with employees, allowing them to feel seen and heard at work.
Employees are often the most confident when they aren’t micro-managed or fear making mistakes or taking justified risks. When leaders trust employees to manage their time and success responsibly, the results often speak for themselves.
Deal breaker #5 – Employees have no mission or purpose
People want to feel valued, supported and connected to a purpose. This evolving priority is especially true in the hybrid workplace, which today has taken permanent root in some form among many employers. Creating that environment requires intentional leadership and open communication, especially in a hybrid workplace.
Younger professionals are increasingly seeking genuine input and impact. They want to know their work matters. Offering opportunities for volunteerism, community engagement or purpose-driven initiatives, for both those championed by the company or those of the employee’s own choosing, helps fulfill that need while strengthening loyalty to the organization.
The market for top talent is stronger than the news suggests. Employers that treat people as replaceable will struggle to keep them. Those businesses that invest in culture, through listening, transparency, flexibility, development and human connection, will not just attract great talent, but will retain them long-term, greatly contributing to the overall success of the company. Leadership and hiring managers that ignore recruiter insights, employee feedback, or market realities often lose great talent, not because the offer wasn’t monetarily competitive, but because the culture wasn’t compelling or attractive.
At the end of the day, people want to succeed, earn well and feel appreciated at a company where work-life balance is prioritized and employees are humanized. When leadership makes creating a positive and engaging culture a daily practice rather than a talking point, employee loyalty and commitment follows.
About the Author: Elizabeth Jacobs brings over 20 years of experience in Executive Search and is a recognized expert in Chief Financial Officer search and leads the Finance, Accounting, and Human Resources search divisions as Executive Vice President at StevenDouglas. Elizabeth started with the firm in 2002, and since that time has substantially grown the Finance and Accounting Search practice first throughout Florida and then expanded the practice nationally.
Elizabeth has been honored as one of South Florida’s Top 25 Most Influential Business Women by the South Florida Business Journal. She enjoys working closely with clients, helping them explore their current and future hiring needs, as well as identifying individuals that will thrive within their culture. Her practice is focused on providing financial executives for emerging middle market to Fortune 500 companies, and specialties include general accounting, financial reporting, finance, treasury, tax and audit searches from mid-level management to C-level executive placement.
